On UrbanBaby: Is it OK to breastfeed in public?

BNET Insight

Sterling Performance

Spotlight on UK business and management

Tesco Employees 'Vent' with Nasty Facebook Posts

January 19th, 2009 @ 1:30 pm

Categories: Management, Motivation, Talent Management, Workplace

Tags: Facebook, Tesco, Social Networking, Balanced Scorecard, Online Communications, Marketing, Advertising & Promotion, Marketing Research, Joanna Higgins

 whining.jpg

Social networking can be a valuable part of a company’s employment strategy. But some businesses are still coming to terms with its darker aspects, with Tesco just the latest to discover how nasty online staff exchanges can become, according to a news posting on Brand Republic.

Tesco staff who set up a Facebook group called “Tesco employees could rule the world” used it to vent about the chain’s customers, who are characterised as pestering, smelly and cheap in a series of complaints.

When being asked by a customer where to find a product, one employee’s instinct was to say: “Give me your shopping list, you senile old cow, and I’ll do your shopping for you. Just leave me alone.”

“I wish these f******s would just stay at home and shop online!” added another member of the group, which carried the gripes of some 60 Tesco employees.

Last year, Virgin Atlantic’s staff had the same urges and 13 found themselves facing the sack after they contributed to a group that speculated as to the airline’s safety record and called passengers “chavs”.

It’s a reminder of how far we have to go when it comes to service in the UK. According to this online complaints test, bad service is one of the top three complaints (among those who’ve done the survey.)

Grumpy, unwelcoming service and (another in the top three) high costs threaten to put visitors off Britain, according to an interview of VisitBritain’s chairman, Christopher Rodrigues.

But according to research by the Institute of Customer Service, customer service is improving across the UK — with retail leading the way. So are the likes of Tesco and Virgin isolated? It’s unlikely.

“This is not the first time a major UK company has been embarrassed by some of its staff on a social networking site, when frustrations with customers have caused offence,” says Duncan Baker of the Institute of Customer Service.

Nor is the first time shop staff — or anyone customer-facing — have ‘gathered’ to have a good old gripe about their customers.

But the problem for Tesco is that its unhappy employees have broadcast their dissatisfaction across the internet. Worse, perhaps, may be the fact that forum contributors are siding with the staff — why shouldn’t they have a rant, asks one, while another points out how “atrocious” some customers can be.

Few people can love their job 24/7, and maybe retail jobs, which are often minimum wage, will always be worthy of a bit more griping. But there seems to be a lot of bile in the Tesco group commentary — is this really “just letting off steam”?

Its employees should’ve known better than to post their frustrations online for all to see. But the retailer, which adapted Kaplan and Norton’s “Balanced Scorecard” to create a service-oriented “Steering Wheel” that specifically encourages employee empowerment, might want to look behind the comments at what’s making its staff so angry.

 (Photo: yummiec00kies, cc2.0)

 
Reply to Story

BNET TalkbackShare your ideas and expertise on this topic

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

  •  
    1

    themybigtoecompany

    01/20/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Tesco Employees 'Vent' with Nasty Facebook Posts

    Social Networking {'SN') sites in their purest form serve a purpose - getting staff to offer their heartfelt thoughts is the very essence of Employee Engagement strategies. Where SN sites irk employers is where such raw comments 'go public'. So the challenge for employers like Tesco is how to encourage, channel and use those feelings positively for the betterment of their customer service offering. The use of annual employee surveys, focus groups and other people-centric activities usually help... but UK plc values freedom of speech and original free-thinking but over T'internet? Every little helps they say!

  •  
    2

    Karen Steen

    01/20/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Tesco Employees 'Vent' with Nasty Facebook Posts

    Customer service is not much better in the U.S. these days, according to
    Jeffrey Pfeffer's post today in The Corner Office. As Pfeffer proves, the venting can go both ways.

    Karen Steen
    Senior Editor, BNET

  •  
    3

    percychow

    01/21/09 | Report as spam

    REPLY: Tesco Employees 'Vent' with Nasty Facebook Posts

    [ shrugs ]

    People (customers or counter persons) offend us - we
    absorb the offense, and we are congratulated for
    having self-control or maturity.

    The problem is, we absorb these offenses and have
    very few outlets in which to, well let them out.

    The internet can be a very therapeutic source of
    tension release, especially when you find others in a
    similar situation as yourself (misery loves company
    after all).

    Dear Tesco and Virgin, consider this... as part of your
    employee training, perhaps also offer training on how
    to accept criticism or rejection. I know it's a stupid
    idea but... what if Osama Bin Laden was taught to
    accept/deal with people or ideaologies different from
    his own?

  •  
    4

    ColinSlater

    02/02/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Tesco Employees 'Vent' with Nasty Facebook Posts

    It is very disturbing to see how far and how deep that the selfish and self-centric attitude has penetrated into the somewhat dim brains of our society.

    It would be interesting to find out what exactly these people perceive is the function of their job as Tesco. Is it simply filling shelves, or swiping product barcodes over laser readers or do they expect to turn up at the store, spend the time required to get paid and go home with no expectation of providing Tesco with any form of service.

    It is deeply worrying that there is no perception or self-awareness from these employees and their attitudes to inconvenient customers is truly stupid, without "customers" there wouldn't be a Tesco and without Tesco they wouldn't have a Job and then who would be dirty, smelly and pathetic. Do these same people never ask for service in shops they visit and if so what do they expect from the people serving them and do they make an effort not to do silly things or make silly errors.

    Never mind training them to accept rejection, perhaps a course in growing-up and developing a mature attitude is what is required.

  •  
    5

    andrew@...

    02/02/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Tesco Employees 'Vent' with Nasty Facebook Posts

    I worked at Tesco for about 4 years and left in May 2008 to restart my IT career. I can tell you why people vent their frustration because the working conditions are terrible! The managers don't tend to back you up if you are right and this makes you look stupid in front of customers.

    Managers also do not appreciate what you do and instead jump on you when they feel something else should be done as well as the thing you are doing.

    I had a few incidents with both managers and supervisors at Tesco. Each time I put the manager in their place and made them realise how wrong they were! A lot of staff who work at Tesco are not strong enough to confront managers and so just accept managers jumping on them and making them feel like crap!

    I however am not! I am glad to have left, and do not envision ever going back!

  •  
    6

    bbwalters@...

    02/03/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Tesco Employees 'Vent' with Nasty Facebook Posts

    I recenlty asked a tesco employee, at Port Talbot, where a particular product was, I was too busy to brouse the shelves, as women seem to do. I was treated with courtesy and pointed correctly to the location.
    Having said that, I travel on the continent quite a lot and have found the attitude of Supermarket employees are very much more into customer service and help. They understand who pays their wages, i.e. the customer.

  •  
    7

    aufo8mycow

    02/09/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Tesco Employees 'Vent' with Nasty Facebook Posts

    I think it's great.. I own my IT company in West Devon and would encourage all my staff to say how they feel, even if that is at the expense of rude customers.. The fact is, staff are not an emotional punchbag to be sworn at and worse by customers, they are there to be polite and offer a service.. that's all. We have all witnessed the fed up customer, who take their frustration out on someone (even when the customer is in the wrong) Airport on Sky is a prime example of how wrong and rude a customer can be! Only difference is, the retail trade has one of the highest rates of assults by customers in the UK. Some staff members are even killed.. because some idiot had had enough?.. this is a right is it?

    Fact is there is a lot of stupid, rude, chav'y.. you name it.. customers in the UK.. a lot of whom use Tesco, the staff of which are treated poorly by Tesco PLC.. The Management.. The world.. and rightly so, they have had enough!

    I say to them you go right ahead.. you make the UK shoppers understand what a bunch of rude, lowlife, scum sucking, worthless, moaning bags of sh't they really are.. and with it.. they might change! and if you feel better for it.. power to you! and for each reader of this who thinks Tesco should sack them.. I reakon your one of those customers with more chips on your shoulder than isle 7.. GET OVER IT!

  •  
    8

    500quid.com

    02/09/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Tesco Employees 'Vent' with Nasty Facebook Posts

    A few years ago my income took a sudden sharp downturn and I had to find work very quickly in order to meet the mortgage payment. I took a short-term job in my local supermarket and have to say that 99% of the customers were very polite and respectful towards me. I like to think that I delivered a high level of customer service in return.

    Unfortunately, not all of my colleagues did the same.

    The root cause of the problem was how the staff were treated by the store management team.

    A lot of company executives genuinely believe their personal philosophies of how to treat people will be put into practice on the shop floor. However, the line managers who deal with the staff on a day to day basis are under so much pressure to deliver better margins that the company philosophy gets lost somewhere along the way.

    When executives visit individual shops to check on how they are doing, the shop management team are always tipped off in advance so they are able to put on a good show during the executive's visit including, in some cases, giving the day off to the more "troublesome" employees.

    It is very rare these days for a company executive to know what really goes on on their shop floors.

  •  
    9

    WHYMORE

    02/23/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Tesco Employees 'Vent' with Nasty Facebook Posts

    I Worked for Tesco's for almost 7 Years .I worked in 4 different stores from small stores to big superstores ... It was a mix of full time and Later Part Time Job as i Realised within a couple of Years after working their that i will newer stay and carry on working in Tescos after i finish my Studies ...
    I feel that i have almost wasted my time , as i have seen Tesco's standard going Down Year afer Year , and the Profits Going up Year after Year .. The Outsiders Newer Know How much Pressure the Tesco's employes work with , You get these ill manered or uneducated Managers ( Promoted from General Assistant Levels ) They just have some kind of Attitude or Mental Problems ..
    In one store i was given some activity by store manager to keep an eye on these Managers who came with recomondations , and i was not surpriced to find that those managers newer knew how to treat their Subordinates ..
    The general employes
    working conditions are really very terrible .. i fully agree what one person said that " The managers don't tend to back you up if you are right and this makes you look stupid in front of customers " ..
    They only know one thing that how to reduce the TOTAL Working hours of that perticular Department and when people Protest they say that they have been told to do so by the Head Office or by the Store or Senior Managers ...
    They are the Trading Managers who try to show the Zonal Managers that they were Successfull in incresing the stores Profits and Hence are entitled for Bonuses ( oh Yes ) Shares and More Free Shares with increment in Salaries for Senior Managers .....
    and the General Employes Can not complaint to our own PERSONAL MANAGERS because of simple reasons that they do not want their Bonuses to be cut ... they can pramote any one .. you should know how to kiss their A*** ..

    so in this condition if we give the customers a moderate service their should not be so much Hussle .. People some times expect to much from some Stores .. when their is zero or NO Motivation in staff ..
    Personal Managers do not work for staff how can they expect ORDINARY EMPLOYES to work for COMMON AND GENERAL CUSTOMERS ......

  •  
    10

    moomoomoo1

    03/19/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Tesco Employees 'Vent' with Nasty Facebook Posts

    I worked in retail for over 5 years, and I fully back the staffs right to vent. I've been spat at, physically threatened, verbally abused... I've had to confront druggies and thieves for just over minimum wage, come in at 2am to set up a promotion campaign and do countless hours of unpaid overtime - shop staff are not mindless, ill-educated morons who cease to exist as soon as customers walk out the door, and the sooner they start treating staff like human beings the sooner they will receive the same in kind.

  •  
    11

    eliza,garber

    05/13/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Tesco Employees 'Vent' with Nasty Facebook Posts

    What worries me, not more but equally, is the number of Facebook groups set up by customers to fervently express their hatred for brands (the global company I work for very much included). I visited one of these groups lately and found that beyond exchanging expletives, customers were sharing real shock stories, including one 22 yr-old customer's scanned ?50k billing error. That's going to do some damage!

    Yet so few companies seem to be engaging these customers to allay the problems and participate in conversations to find out what needs to change (mine included again). Social networking is still relatively new to organisations and I don't think they recognise yet the damage a negative presence can do.

Please add your comment:

  1. You are currently: a Guest |
  2.  

Basic HTML tags that work in comments are: bold (<b></b>), italic (<i></i>), underline (<u></u>), and hyperlink (<a href></a>)

advertisement
advertisement
advertisement